Itay Savion, Founder

Cyber Insurance and Cybersecurity: What Insurers Actually Expect

Glowing blue digital dome over a grid with a warm amber core, representing cybersecurity and cyber insurance working together to protect a growing business

Cyber insurance has become an important part of risk management for many growing businesses, but there is a common misunderstanding about how it works. Some business owners assume buying cyber insurance transfers their cybersecurity risk to the insurer. Others assume strong cybersecurity makes insurance unnecessary. Neither is true. That misunderstanding is where I see businesses get caught twice: once by the incident, and once by the claim.

Cybersecurity and cyber insurance solve different parts of the same problem. Cybersecurity reduces the likelihood and impact of an incident. Cyber insurance can help manage certain financial consequences if an insured incident occurs, subject to the policy’s terms, conditions, exclusions, deductibles, and limits. For growing businesses, the two increasingly need to work together.

Cyber Insurance Is Not a Replacement for Cybersecurity

Think about commercial property insurance: having it does not mean you can remove the locks and disable the alarm. The insurer expects reasonable precautions. Cyber insurance works the same way; insurers want to understand how you protect your systems, accounts, data, and operations before they price your risk.

Requirements vary by insurer, industry, size, technology environment, and claims history, but several controls appear repeatedly in underwriting guidance.

1. Multi-Factor Authentication

MFA requires an extra form of verification beyond a password, and it matters because stolen credentials remain one of the most common ways attackers get in. Insurers want to know whether MFA protects email, Microsoft 365 or Google Workspace, remote access, administrative accounts, cloud systems, and critical business applications.

Simply saying “yes, we have MFA” does not tell the full story. The real question is where it is actually enforced. If it protects ordinary employees but not administrators or remote access, a real blind spot still exists. I always ask specifically which accounts are exempt, because that answer usually tells you more than anything else on the list.

2. Endpoint Detection and Response

Traditional antivirus is no longer enough on its own. EDR gives greater visibility into suspicious activity on computers and servers and can help identify malicious behavior. For growing businesses, EDR has become increasingly important in cyber-risk evaluation, and insurers also care whether it is actively monitored, not just installed. An endpoint platform can generate an excellent alert, but if nobody reviews or responds to it, you are still exposed. Alert fatigue is real, and I would rather see a smaller set of alerts someone actually reads than a dashboard full of noise nobody opens.

3. Backups and Recovery

Backups are particularly important when insurers evaluate ransomware exposure. But having a backup is only the beginning: you should know what is backed up, how often, where it is stored, whether it is separated from production systems, who can access or delete it, whether restoration has been tested, and how quickly you could actually recover.

Travelers, for example, recommends frequent, systematic backups that are separated appropriately and regularly tested, and that is a reasonable bar regardless of which insurer is actually asking. The real question is not “Do we have backups?” It is “Could we actually recover our business from them?”

4. Security Updates and Vulnerability Management

Known vulnerabilities create a direct path into an organization, so insurers want to understand how you manage updates, particularly for systems exposed to the internet. You need a process for identifying missing updates, known vulnerabilities, unsupported software, exposed systems, and weak configurations, plus clear responsibility for fixing the serious ones.

The goal is not patching everything instantly. It is knowing which weaknesses create the greatest risk and addressing them by severity and exposure. That prioritization, more than the patching itself, is usually where I see programs succeed or fail.

5. Privileged and Administrative Access

Administrative accounts give significant control over company systems, so if an attacker compromises one, the damage is far greater than a standard employee account. You should know who has admin access, why they need it, whether separate admin accounts are used, whether MFA protects them, and whether access is reviewed and removed when no longer needed.

As businesses grow, privileged access accumulates quietly through role changes, IT suppliers, and contractors, so controlling it is both a security issue and a way to demonstrate effective risk management. A quick audit of who actually has admin rights almost always turns up more names than expected.

6. Email Security and Employee Awareness

Attackers often target employees because convincing a person is easier than defeating a technical control. Phishing, fake invoices, credential theft, executive impersonation, and payment fraud can all start with an email. Combine technical protections with employee awareness, and pay particular attention to anyone who can transfer money, change banking details, access sensitive information, or approve transactions. Technology catches most of it, but the remainder usually finds the one person who is rushed and does not stop to check. Cybersecurity is not only an IT responsibility.

7. Security Monitoring

Installing security tools does not automatically mean you are being monitored. For businesses without an internal security operations team, the central question is: who is watching when something suspicious happens? That is usually the first place weaknesses show up in a new environment. Monitoring and response capability matter more as your technology environment grows more complex.

8. Incident Response Planning

Insurers also want to understand how prepared you are to respond when something goes wrong. A plan should define who leads the response, who contacts IT and cybersecurity providers, how systems get isolated, who contacts the insurer, when legal counsel gets involved, and how operations continue.

Government cybersecurity guidance recommends maintaining and exercising these plans before an incident occurs; a plan that has never been discussed or tested provides limited value. A tested plan is the difference between a bad day and a bad month.

9. Business Continuity

Cyber incidents become business incidents quickly. If email disappears for two days, can employees still work? If an accounting system goes down, can invoices still be processed? Business continuity and cybersecurity are closely connected because the financial impact of an incident often depends on how fast you can resume operations. This is the piece businesses tend to underestimate the most, in my view.

The Cyber Insurance Application Matters

Take the insurance application seriously and answer questions about MFA, backups, monitoring, and other controls accurately. Do not assume a control exists just because you bought a product; there is a real difference between owning an MFA-capable platform and actually enforcing MFA for all relevant users and systems.

Understand what is genuinely implemented before describing your environment to an insurer, and when in doubt, verify the technical facts internally and loop in a qualified insurance professional for policy questions.

What Happens If You Do Not Meet Every Requirement?

Not every organization starts with every control perfectly implemented, and that does not necessarily rule out cyber insurance. Requirements vary between insurers, and an insurer may evaluate your overall risk, request more information, recommend improvements, or adjust coverage and pricing accordingly.

The important thing is not waiting until the final stages of an application to understand your posture: identifying weak points earlier gives you time to fix them properly.

Cyber Insurance Can Actually Improve Cybersecurity

The application process has an unexpected benefit: it forces you to answer questions you may never have asked yourself. Is MFA really enabled everywhere? Are backups tested? Who monitors alerts?

These are useful questions regardless of whether insurance is involved, and underwriting can act as another form of risk assessment, exposing the difference between what management assumes and what is actually happening.

Cybersecurity Should Come Before the Application

The wrong time to discover major weaknesses is while filling out an insurance questionnaire. Evaluate your environment before applying or renewing:

  • Identity and MFA configuration
  • Endpoint protection
  • Vulnerability management
  • Backup and recovery
  • Administrative access
  • Email security
  • Security monitoring
  • Employee awareness
  • Incident response
  • Business continuity

This gives you a clearer picture of what is working and makes conversations with your insurance professional more productive.

Insurance and Security Should Work Together

No cybersecurity program can guarantee an incident will never happen, and no insurance policy eliminates the disruption or pressure a serious cyberattack brings. The stronger approach combines both: cybersecurity reduces risk, cyber insurance helps transfer certain financial risks, and incident preparation helps you recover. Together, they form a broader cyber-risk management strategy.

For a growing business, cybersecurity has become too important to manage through assumptions. Before an application or renewal, know what controls are actually in place and whether they are working as expected.

The best time to find a cybersecurity weakness is before an attacker does, and before an insurer asks about it.

Blog

More blog posts

View all posts
Payment path on a blueprint grid splitting at a verification phone call: one route leads to the real supplier’s construction site, the other to a fraudulent bank account
Itay Savion, Founder

The Supplier Payment That Reached the Wrong Bank Account

A construction company receives an email from a regular supplier. The supplier explains that it has changed banks and provides new payment instructions for a pending invoice. The message arrives

Streams of code on a dark screen with highlighted hacker warnings, illustrating the biggest cyber risks facing small and mid-sized businesses
Itay Savion, Founder

The Biggest Cyber Risks Facing Small and Mid-Sized Businesses Today

Cyberattacks are not only a problem for large corporations.Growing businesses are attractive targets. They depend on cloud applications, email, online banking, remote access, and third-party providers, often with smaller security

WISP checklist with an open padlock – accounting firm cybersecurity
Itay Savion, Founder

A Written Security Plan Is Not Enough: Is Your Accounting Firm Actually Protected?

An employee at an accounting firm receives an email that appears to come from the IRS, a tax software provider, or an existing client. It asks them to review an

Contact Us